Probably my best read of the year. Twan Eng returns in his second novel to Malaysia, initially in present times but interspersed with the period just after WWII ended, and the Malaysian Emergency reached its height. While the Communist guerrillas were carrying out a campaign of murder and terror against farmers, miners and villagers, the Malaysian Nationalists were simultaneously trying to wrest power from  British Colonial authorities – a turbulent time.  Interestingly, as a historical aside, apparently this is the only time that a guerrilla war was won by the authorities (i.e. the Brits) and not by the insurgents.

The book resonated with me for days after I had finished reading it, as I kept remembering incidents and characters from the complex and haunting tale. The main protagonist is a Chinese woman, who survives internment in a Japanese slave labour camp and ultimately goes on to qualify as a lawyer and became a Supreme Court Judge.  This story would, on its own, form the basis of other lesser novels.  But there are other equally  strong characters in the tale.  The person I found the most fascinating was the enigmatic Japanese Aritomo Nakamura, one-time gardener to the Emperor of Japan (pre-war) now resident in the Cameron Highlands of Malaysia, and architect of an exquisite Japanese style garden, on a remote hillside.  Again, Aritomo’s story in the hands of a lesser novelist would have been a book on its own.  As the book progresses we learn about Japanese archery as a meditation, we learn about the art of woodblock prints and the arcane practice of horimono  which I found utterly fascinating, and which  is an integral (and important) part of the story.

There’s a South African link in the story too.  Aritomo’s neighbour is an ex-pat South African who emigrated to Malaya in the 1930s to become a tea-planter. Magnus, the tea-planter and his family are important characters in the unfolding story. As part of their story we get a chunk of South African history as well – but not an indigestible chunk.

Tan Twan Eng currently divides his time between Malaysia and Cape Town, South Africa, and I’ve had the privilege of hearing him speak about his first novel The Gift of Rain. He’s alarmingly well informed and articulate, and passionate about his home country, Malaysia.

Tan Twan Eng is such a versatile writer.  His book contains the  history of Malaysia, alongside a  WWII mystery concerning looted treasure (which other novelists would have simply have written as a Raiders of the Lost Ark extravaganza, but TTE is way beyond such a facile approach) coupled with evocative descriptions of the jungle and tea-gardens, as well as tenderly romantic interludes – which, effortlessly, are beautiful and poetic without being artsy-fartsy or mawkish – whatever he’s doing he gets it just right.

I cannot recommend this book too highly.  At the time of writing I learn that the book has made in onto the Booker Long List. It deserves to be on the Booker Short List and if it were up to me, I would award it the Man Booker Prize.  However, given the MB Judges extraordinary predilection for choosing obscure, unreadable, very literary novels, my hopes are not too high. But enough of my griping.  Read this book: it’s marvellous!


Filed under BOOK REVIEWS

10 responses to “RECENT READS # 18 : THE GARDEN OF EVENING MISTS – Tan Twan Eng

  1. Eileen Turner

    Most interesting, Alison. I am currently leaving until later Oriental authors, having had a surfrit og them recently, I always enjoy your blog. Have a good holiday, Love Eileen and Eric


  2. i’ll give this one a read! i needed a book suggestion today


  3. Great post, thanks, I read ” The gift of Rain” while in Penang and really enjoyed it, now I’ll look out for ” The Garden of Evening Mists”. Thanks


  4. Thanks for your wonderful review of this book! I hope to read it next year. I loved The Gift of Rain!


  5. Ingrid Torsay

    Alison, I am new to your blog. Just finished reading this beautifully-written book. It is my turn to lead book club later this month, so I have made it my choice. SPOILER ALERT: Are we to infer that the treasure is buried in the garden? Any explanation would be appreciated.


    • Welcome to my blog. No, I didn’t make that link to the garden. Our Book Club also bought the novel & we all loved it, with one exception. What else does your Bk Club read?


  6. Searching I noticed your website book-marked as: RECENT READS # 18 :
    THE GARDEN OF EVENING MISTS – Tan Twan Eng | despatchesfromtimbuktu.
    I am assuming you book-marked it yourself and wanted to
    ask if social bookmarking gets you a good deal of traffic?
    I’ve been thinking about doing some book-marking for a few of my websites but wasn’t sure if it would generate any positive
    results. Thank you so much.


  7. Dear Alison, I really enjoyed reading your review – have the book on the groaning shelves and this has encouraged me to reach for it earlier, thanks to your glowing comments. Thanks, Nicola


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s